Affirmation: Gay & Lesbian Mormons

Research Links Some Scriptures to Hostile Acts
Those with a stronger religious background responded with slightly more hostility

March 2007

From a story in the Deseret Morning News.

A study of 490 students — 248 of them at Brigham Young University — suggests a correlation between exposure to scriptural violence that is condoned by God and increased aggression. University of Michigan psychologist Brad Bushman, BYU professor Robert Ridge and three other researchers co-wrote "When God Sanctions Killing," which will appear in the March issue of Psychological Science magazine.

About a year ago, Ridge recruited 95 male and 153 female students from Brigham Young University to participate in the project. They were selected to represent a population of people who are strongly religious. Ninety-nine percent of the students reported having a belief in God and the Bible. The students were given extra credit for their participation.

In addition to the BYU students, 110 male and 132 female students from Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, participated in the study. These students were chosen because they represented a more diverse population of people with different religious backgrounds. Of the group, 50 percent said they believe in God and 27 percent said they believe in the Bible. To do the study, both groups of students were shown a passage of scripture from the Old Testament that contained tales of beatings, rape and murder. Half of the students were shown an additional passage that included violent retribution as sanctioned by God. The other half was not. The students who were not shown the additional passage were told the story came from an ancient scroll. The others were told it came from the Bible.

Members of both the religious and non-religious groups who were exposed to the additional verse responded with greater aggression in a subsequent test than did those who did not read the passage. In the test, participants were placed in groups of two. Each person was given headphones and a "weapon" — a button that would produce a noise frequency that could be as loud as a smoke alarm. The students each pressed a button as fast as possible for 25 trials and the slowest of the pair would receive a blast in the ears. The winning button-pusher could choose how loud to make the sound in the other person's ears. Aggression was measured by the frequency with which the winning students blasted their partners.

The study indicated that those with a stronger religious background responded with slightly more hostility — and louder blasts — than those who were not as religious.